This Q&A session focused on addressing questions about non-Jews who are in the process of conversion or keeping mitzvahs, particularly why they might feel guilty or inconsistent when they don’t follow their chosen practices. Chaim explained that while non-Jews are not obligated to keep Jewish laws, they may still feel bad when they don’t maintain consistency because they are on a path toward conversion and want to please their creator. He discussed how taking on even small mitzvahs consistently is more powerful than attempting large commitments that are difficult to maintain, using the example of Rav Shach who took on saying grace after meals from a prayer book rather than memory. The conversation also covered topics like the placebo effect of keeping kosher, the concept of Jewish souls having specific character traits (baishanim, rachmanim, and gimos chassadim), and whether non-Jews can demonstrate a Godly soul through keeping universal moral laws. Chaim emphasized that while non-Jews may not have the same spiritual obligations as Jews, keeping the seven Noahide laws can make them more righteous and moral, even if they don’t convert.
Non-Jews and Kosher Obligations
Chaim discussed the question of why non-Jews might feel different when they don’t follow Jewish practices, particularly regarding keeping kosher. He explained that according to the Kli Yakar commentary, non-Jews are not obligated to keep kosher because it doesn’t affect their souls, as they eat various foods without spiritual impact. Chaim noted that while some might feel different emotionally when breaking these practices, the religious obligation only applies to Jews due to its effect on Jewish souls.
Dietary Restrictions and Spiritual Consistency
Chaim discussed the concept of dietary restrictions and their spiritual effects, arguing that while these restrictions may not directly affect the soul, they impact people’s consistency in their religious practices. He explained that individuals on a path toward conversion or deepening their Jewish practice need to maintain consistency, even if they feel the restrictions have no direct effect. Chaim emphasized that consistency, particularly in quality rather than quantity, is crucial for reaching one’s spiritual goals, and highlighted how inconsistency can lead to feelings of failure and distraction from the ultimate goal of conversion or spiritual growth.
Consistency in Small Actions
Chaim discussed the importance of focusing on small, consistent actions rather than taking on large goals that are difficult to maintain. He used the example of Rav Shach, who chose to consistently read Grace after meals from a prayer book rather than taking on more complex religious practices. Chaim explained that taking on small, achievable tasks is more powerful than setting unattainable goals, as consistency is key to long-term success. He also addressed the question of why someone might feel bad about not following religious obligations, suggesting that for non-Jews, such practices would have no practical effect and might be done primarily out of a desire to please their creator.
Religious Consistency and Personal Growth
Chaim discussed the challenges of maintaining consistency in religious practices and personal growth, emphasizing how inconsistency can lead to a loss of meaning and purpose. He explained that even when people are not formally obligated to follow certain practices, they may still feel guilty for not trying to please their creator. Chaim noted that perfectionism can exacerbate these feelings of inadequacy, leading some individuals to give up hope.
Psychological Impact of Unattainable Goals
Chaim discussed the psychological impact of failure when people set unattainable goals, explaining that the danger lies not in temporary setbacks but in losing hope entirely. He used the example of Lyle Alzado, a former football player who fell into a severe brain tumor after fainting due to steroid use, to illustrate how people can feel completely defeated when they cannot achieve what they set out to do. Chaim emphasized that while some people may continue trying after failure, others might abandon their efforts completely, which he identified as more dangerous than temporary setbacks.
Thoughts and Speech Connections
Chaim discussed how past experiences and impressions remain stored in the mind, even if not actively thought about, using examples like movie scenes and commercial jingles to illustrate this point. He explained that when people make statements, they necessarily thought about those ideas beforehand, making it impossible to claim they didn’t mean what they said. Chaim used the example of a basketball player who made inappropriate comments during a live stream to demonstrate how thoughts that manifest as speech reflect internal beliefs, even if the person later tries to dismiss or apologize for those statements.
Clarifying and Avoiding Miscommunication
Chaim discussed the challenges of clarifying statements, particularly when someone says something offensive or inappropriate. He emphasized that even if someone didn’t intend to say something harmful, they still meant what came out, and the key is to be very careful about what is said. Chaim shared examples of how miscommunication can occur and stressed the importance of ensuring clarity in conversations to avoid misunderstandings. He concluded by advising to take responsibility for statements made and ensure absolute clarity to prevent disputes over what was said.
Words and Jewish Conversion Discussion
Chaim discussed the importance of being careful with words and the consequences of making statements that may be misinterpreted. He emphasized that what a person says often reflects their true thoughts, and retracting statements doesn’t change the fact that they were meant. Chaim also addressed questions about Jewish ancestry and conversion, explaining that having Jewish ancestry alone does not make someone Jewish, and conversion requires a Jewish mother or proof of Jewish heritage.
Jewish Conversion and Obligations
Chaim discussed the concept of Jewish conversion and obligations, explaining that individuals without sufficient proof of Jewish ancestry would need to convert regardless of their percentage of Jewish heritage. He emphasized that even though these individuals are not legally obligated to keep Jewish laws, the process still holds meaning and significance for them. Chaim advised that when discussing conversion with others, it’s important to acknowledge that the process is challenging and that most people drop out before completion, so potential converts should be questioned about their genuine motivation for continuing.
Personal Life Decision and Judaism
Chaim discussed his personal experience with a significant life decision made over 30 years ago, emphasizing that he would make the same choice despite the consequences, including losing family and friends. He addressed how others may question or harass him about his decision, but he remains firm in his path. Chaim also touched on the broader issue of people not thinking critically or researching topics before forming opinions, using the example of political narratives about Israel. The discussion concluded with a question about how to help someone who is halachically Jewish but lacks knowledge of Judaism, to which Chaim suggested referring them to local Chabad for guidance on understanding their Jewish heritage.
Jewish Character and Ancestry Discussion
Chaim discussed the importance of evidence and facts in discussions, emphasizing that claims should be based on research rather than emotions. He explained three character traits commonly associated with Jewish people: bashfulness, compassion, and acts of loving kindness. Chaim also addressed the concept of Jewish ancestry and conversion, suggesting that non-Jews might be drawn to convert due to a connection to the Torah and their soul’s presence at Mount Sinai.
Divine Decree in Jewish Law
Chaim discussed the concept of divine decree in Jewish law, using the example of the mitzvah to shoo away a mother bird before taking eggs. He explained that while this practice might seem cruel to non-Jews, it must be followed as a divine command regardless of understanding, similar to other mitzvahs like keeping Shabbos or not mixing milk and meat. Chaim emphasized that while complete understanding may not be necessary, one must act on mitzvahs to the best of their ability, drawing a parallel to everyday actions like flying on a plane or driving a car where complete understanding isn’t required for execution.
Divine Commands and Religious Identity
Chaim discussed the concept of divine commands in religion, explaining that if he were to create a new religion as a prophet, he would make the commands simple and easy to follow rather than complex. He emphasized that religious practices don’t need to make logical sense when they come from a divine source, as people follow them due to belief in the command rather than understanding. Chaim also addressed questions about Jewish identity and conversion, explaining that according to Jewish texts, non-Jews possess an animalistic soul but lack the specific spiritual soul that Jews have, and discussed how to approach individuals with mixed religious backgrounds.
Judaism and Non-Jewish Souls
Chaim discussed the concept of souls in Judaism, explaining that while non-Jews have a nefesh behamis (animalistic soul) rather than a complete Jewish soul, they can still achieve righteousness by keeping universal moral laws. He emphasized that even non-Jews who don’t convert can sanctify their souls through moral behavior, modesty, and going against the world’s tide, making them better than others who don’t follow these principles. The discussion concluded with a brief question about burial in Jewish cemeteries, where Chaim noted that while some cemeteries may bury patrilineal Jews, they should not bury non-Jews, though he couldn’t speak definitively about the verification process.
🔔 Subscribe for Torah insights and real conversations about Jewish life: https://www.youtube.com/@beyond Orthodox Conversion to Judaism
🌐 Go deeper: Blog (longer explanations): orthodoxconversion.com Facebook (updates & clips): Beyond Orthodox Conversion to Judaism Email (direct insights): rabbichaimcoffman@gmail.com